Dining 🍽️

Bakery Cafe · American · Anna Maria

The #1 breakfast spot on AMI. Charming cottage cafe on Gulf Drive serving homemade pastries, fresh-baked goods, egg dishes, and the best coffee on the island. Arrive early — it fills up fast.

Cafe · Breakfast & Brunch · Holmes Beach

Bright, cheerful cafe known for creative egg dishes, fresh fruit bowls, avocado toast, and specialty coffee. A local favorite for a relaxed morning meal before hitting the beach.

Coffee · Café · Breakfast · Holmes Beach

A beloved local gem tucked in the heart of Holmes Beach. Expertly crafted espresso drinks, nitro cold brew, fresh New York bagels, and grab-and-go breakfast bites. Cozy, laid-back vibe — neighbors become friends here.

American · Beachfront · Holmes Beach

The only restaurant on AMI that is literally on the beach — dine with your toes in the sand. Full breakfast menu including famous all-you-can-eat pancakes with sausage. Unbeatable Gulf views.

Donuts · Bakery · Anna Maria

Build-your-own artisan donuts with your choice of base, glaze, and toppings. A wildly popular island treat — lines form early on weekends. Cash and card accepted.

Café · Healthy · Breakfast · Anna Maria

Handcrafted espresso drinks, teas, smoothies, açaí bowls, and avocado toast. A health-forward café on Pine Avenue perfect for a light, energizing breakfast or lunch.

American · Cafe · Breakfast · Holmes Beach

A beloved Holmes Beach institution for 20+ years. Hearty, from-scratch breakfast and lunch classics — waffles, omelets, pancakes, and the famous Big Easy Meal. Cash only, warm staff, and a loyal local following.

Deli · Sandwiches · Casual · Holmes Beach

Gourmet deli and island institution. Handcrafted sandwiches, street tacos, Scott's Dogs, and fresh smoothies — all made with locally sourced ingredients. Delivers right to your beach blanket. Family-owned since 2015.

American · Seafood · Anna Maria

Highly rated casual-upscale spot on Gulf Drive with a welcoming porch atmosphere. Signature dishes, fresh fish, specialty spritzers, and top-quality steaks. Closes between lunch and dinner service.

Seafood · Old Florida · Holmes Beach

Classic Old Florida fish shack — now serving at a temporary location while the historic Rod & Reel Pier is rebuilt. Same great grouper, shrimp, and cold beer. Open daily 8am–9pm.

American · Burgers · Holmes Beach

An AMI institution. Picnic tables only, Coca-Cola bottle decor, and totally iconic. Legendary burgers, hot dogs, and cold beer. No frills, all charm — exactly what AMI is about.

BBQ · American · Bradenton Beach

Casual BBQ joint beloved by locals and visitors alike. Slow-smoked meats, loaded sandwiches, and generous portions at fair prices. A go-to for a hearty lunch after a morning on the beach.

Pizza · Casual · Anna Maria

Small, family-friendly pizzeria on Pine Avenue serving handcrafted pizzas and fresh salads made in-house daily with locally sourced produce. Craft beer and wine available.

Mexican · Tacos · Anna Maria

Local, family-owned mission taqueria known for organic, scratch-made tacos, burritos, and bowls. One of the most popular casual spots on Pine Avenue. Order online or walk in.

Seafood · Steam Pots · Takeout · Holmes Beach

Pick up a fresh-packed Bay Bucket® loaded with shrimp, crab, corn, potatoes, and your choice of seasoning. Take it home or to the beach, steam it, and feast. No restaurant wait — just fresh Gulf seafood your way.

Seafood · Casual Bar · Holmes Beach

Lively open-air bar with live music and yard games. Discounted drinks and appetizers during daily happy hour. One of the most popular spots on the island to kick off the evening.

American · Bar & Grill · Holmes Beach

Cozy, casual local favorite on Gulf Drive. Daily happy hour with discounted beer, wine, and cocktails in a laid-back island atmosphere. Great for a post-beach wind-down.

Bar · Frozen Drinks · Bradenton Beach

Rooftop bar on Historic Bridge Street with Gulf-to-Bay views. Famous for frozen daiquiris — half price on 16oz souvenir cups during happy hour, plus $1 off well drinks, wine, and drafts. Live music most nights.

Seafood · American · Holmes Beach

Upscale seafood restaurant with a full liquor bar. Happy hour features $2 off cans, bottles, and draft beers, plus $3 off signature cocktails. Great food specials too — perfect pre-dinner treat.

Mexican · Bar · Bradenton Beach

Colorful Mexican cantina with a generous happy hour — discounted margaritas, beer, and appetizers. One of the longest happy hours on the island. Great for a casual early-evening hangout.

Bar · Dockside · Bradenton Beach

Classic waterfront dive bar and dockside hangout with daily happy hour specials on drinks and food. Arrive by boat or walk in — a true Old Florida experience with cold drinks and bay views.

Irish Pub · Music Hall · Holmes Beach

AMI's beloved Irish pub and music hall on Gulf Drive. Daily happy hour with drink and appetizer specials, plus live music most nights. Karaoke every Monday. One of the best spots for a lively night out on the island.

American · Bar & Grill · Anna Maria

AMI's favorite burger joint with live music every single night. Harry Hour (Mon–Fri 3–5pm) offers $1 off all draft beers, specialty drinks, and house wines. Nightly performers range from blues to acoustic to classic covers. Pet-friendly patio.

BBQ · Tropical · Anna Maria

Casual smoked BBQ spot on historic Pine Avenue in Anna Maria. Fresh, flavorful tropical-inspired BBQ in a relaxed island setting. A local favorite for laid-back lunches and early dinners.

Seafood · Oysters · Casual · Bradenton Beach

Iconic waterfront oyster bar on Historic Bridge Street Pier overlooking the Intracoastal. Arrive by boat — docking available! Oysters 7 ways, fresh grouper, shrimp, and a full bar. The closest AMOB to Anna Maria Island. Happy Hour daily 3–6pm & 9pm–close: $1.99 raw oysters, $3.99 margaritas & drafts.

Seafood · Anna Maria

Iconic beachfront dining right on the Gulf. Fresh seafood, hand-scooped ice cream, and stunning sunset views. Dine indoors, on the deck, or on the beach itself. Reservations highly recommended.

Seafood · Bradenton Beach

Gulf-front beach restaurant with incredible seafood and a climate-friendly outdoor deck. Beautiful oceanfront vistas and signature AMI sunsets every evening.

Continental · Anna Maria Island

Seasonal menu based on the finest local products, prepared in classic form with emphasis on fresh, natural flavors. Picatta, au Poivre, pesto, mojo, and more. Happy Hour Mon–Fri 4–6pm with discounted appetizers, wine, beer, and cocktails.

Seafood & Steaks · Bradenton Beach

2nd and 3rd floor dining above Bridge Street with stunning Gulf views. Rat Pack era ambiance — Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin — with fresh seafood and hand-cut steaks.

Italian · Bradenton Beach

A small, family-owned Italian café inside Island Plaza on Bridge Street. Homemade pasta, fresh-baked bread, and classic Italian dishes in a cozy setting. A local favorite for a relaxed dinner away from the beach crowds.

Italian · Dinner · Holmes Beach

Family-owned authentic Italian eatery next to Duffy's Tavern on Marina Drive. Scratch-made recipes with classic Italian comfort food and modern flavors. Reservations recommended — great for date nights and family gatherings alike.

Contemporary French / American · Anna Maria Island

European-inspired fine dining with American flair. Fresh ingredients, attention to detail, and an exquisite experience for special occasions.

Craft Cocktails · Fine Dining · Holmes Beach

AMI's premier craft cocktail lounge and fine dining destination. True craft cocktails, chef-made bar fare, and elevated dining in a beautiful garden setting. 18+ with valid ID. Book ahead — it fills up fast.

Café · Wine & Beer Bar · Holmes Beach

Café by day, beer and wine bar by night. Handcrafted espresso, smoothies, fresh pastries, and a full breakfast and dinner menu. Sushi chefs on staff. One of the most versatile spots on the island.

Coastal · Seafood · Bradenton Beach

Coastal culinary artistry in a chic, family-friendly atmosphere. Unique menu with fresh flavors and creative preparations. Daily happy hour 3:30–5pm. Reservations recommended.

American · Beachfront · Bradenton Beach

Beachfront restaurant and bar sitting directly on the sugar-white Gulf sands. Full breakfast, lunch, and dinner with stunning Gulf views. The Kokonut Hut is the outdoor beach bar — open late with live music.

American · Bar & Grill · Anna Maria

The local hangout on Anna Maria Island. Sports bar atmosphere with a wide menu — cheesesteaks, pizza, pasta, burgers, and cold beer. Pool tables, TVs, and a welcoming crowd of regulars.

Pizza · Italian · Holmes Beach

Family-owned pizzeria on Marina Drive serving classic round pies, Detroit-style pizza, and grinder sandwiches. A local go-to for casual pizza nights and takeout. Express delivery available.

Burgers · Bar · Holmes Beach

A staple in the community since the 1960s. Famous for the world-famous burger and the coldest beer this side of heaven. Family-owned and operated for over 40 years. A true AMI institution.

Italian · Takeout · Holmes Beach

Little Italy in the heart of Anna Maria Island. Authentic Italian takeout with brick oven pizza, stromboli, and gourmet Italian dinner specials. Outdoor tables available. A hidden gem beloved by locals.

Bar · Lounge · Liquor Store · Anna Maria

Anna Maria Island's iconic neighborhood bar and liquor store, established 1977. A true local institution on Gulf Drive — cold drinks, laid-back atmosphere, and a great spot to meet islanders. Also doubles as a well-stocked liquor store.

Bar & Grille · American · Holmes Beach

AMI's favorite neighborhood hangout on Marina Drive in Holmes Beach. Full bar with a wide selection of liquor, beer, and wine. Trivia night every Tuesday, karaoke every Wednesday, and Happy Hour Fridays. A true local bar with island character.

Mexican · Cali-Mex · Holmes Beach

Family-owned quick-service restaurant with fresh, made-to-order Cali-Mex food. Tacos, burritos, bowls, and legendary guac & chips. Primarily takeout with outdoor seating. Authentic and affordable.

American / Seafood · Longboat Key

Iconic Old Florida dockside dining under century-old buttonwood trees on Sarasota Bay. Locally-sourced, southern-inspired seafood with legendary key lime pie. Arrive by boat at the private dock.

Modern Seafood / Cocktails · Longboat Key

Upscale modern seafood and craft cocktails in a stunning waterfront setting on Longboat Key. Reservations recommended via Resy. Located just south of Longboat Pass — easy drive from AMI.

Seafood / American · Cortez Village

The #1 rated restaurant in Cortez Village on TripAdvisor. Casual waterfront dining with fresh Gulf seafood, burgers, and sandwiches. Outdoor seating with views of the working fishing docks.

Seafood Market & Restaurant · Cortez Village

A Cortez institution since 1940. Fresh-off-the-boat seafood market and dockside restaurant right on the working waterfront. The smoked fish dip is legendary. Watch the shrimp boats unload while you eat.

Seafood / Tiki Bar · Cortez Village

Casual tiki bar and grill in the heart of Cortez Village. Fresh seafood, cold drinks, and a laid-back waterfront atmosphere. A great spot to watch the sunset over Sarasota Bay.

Seafood · Old Florida · Waterfront · Cortez Village

Waterfront seafood restaurant in historic Cortez fishing village — just minutes from the AMI bridge. Old Florida cuisine with fresh Gulf catches, strong cocktails, and live music on weekends. A community landmark since 1999. $3 Busch Light all day.

French · Crepes · Bakery · Anna Maria

A charming French-inspired cafe on Pine Avenue serving authentic crepes, pastries, and espresso drinks. A delightful taste of Paris on Anna Maria Island — perfect for a leisurely breakfast or lunch.

Japanese · Sushi · Asian Fusion · Anna Maria

Fresh sushi, sashimi, and Asian fusion dishes in Anna Maria. A welcome addition to AMI's dining scene for sushi lovers looking for quality rolls and Japanese cuisine on the island.

Juice Bar · Smoothies · Healthy · Anna Maria

Fresh-pressed juices, smoothies, acai bowls, and healthy grab-and-go options. A great stop for a nutritious breakfast or post-beach refreshment in Anna Maria.

Tropical · Bowls · Healthy · Anna Maria

Tropical-inspired bowls, smoothies, and fresh island fare. A fun, casual spot for a healthy meal or snack with a laid-back island vibe on Pine Ave.

Fish & Chips · British · Seafood · Holmes Beach

New Zealand-style fish and chips with fresh Gulf catch, hand-cut fries, and housemade sauces. A unique and delicious take on a classic dish — a must-try for seafood lovers on AMI.

Chicago Style Hot Dogs · American · Casual · Holmes Beach

Authentic Chicago-style hot dogs dragged through the garden, served with crinkle-cut fries. A fun, casual spot on Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach.

Cafe · Breakfast · American · Holmes Beach

A cozy neighborhood cafe serving breakfast and lunch classics with a homemade touch. Known for fresh ingredients, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Bagels · Deli · Breakfast · Holmes Beach

Fresh-baked bagels with a wide variety of cream cheeses, deli sandwiches, and breakfast options. A local favorite for a quick, satisfying morning meal on the island.

American · Comfort Food · Casual · Holmes Beach

Casual American comfort food with creative burgers, sandwiches, and shareable plates. A relaxed, welcoming spot for a satisfying meal in Holmes Beach.

Ice Cream · Desserts · Holmes Beach

Family-owned ice cream shop with 36 flavors including dairy-free, vegan, and sugar-free options. Enjoy ice creams, milkshakes, malts, and sundaes in a welcoming atmosphere on East Bay Dr.

Bakery · Pastries · Cortez Village

Delicious, high-quality baked goods made from scratch with the best ingredients. Located in Cortez Village — a perfect stop before or after exploring the historic fishing village.